Can Protestors Invade Church Services?
In an age of rising political hostility, even our most sacred and private moments are at risk of being politicized.
Recently, a church service in Minneapolis was disrupted when protesters stormed into the sanctuary to confront a pastor over his alleged cooperation with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
Once again, the nation was forced to ask an important question:
Where does free speech end, and where does the right to worship begin?
Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost recently addressed this very issue, offering both legal clarity and practical wisdom for churches navigating an increasingly aggressive public square.
His message was clear: the First Amendment protects speech, but it does not permit intimidation, disruption, or trespass, especially during religious worship.
Free Speech Has Boundaries
One of the most common misunderstandings in today’s culture is the idea that the First Amendment provides a blanket right to speak anywhere, at any time, in any manner.
That is not the law, and it never has been.
As Attorney General Yost explained, constitutional protections have always included what courts call “time, place, and manner” restrictions. In other words, you may have the right to express your views, but that right does not override other fundamental rights, such as the right of a property owner to control access to their space or the right of people to gather peacefully for worship.
You can protest on a public sidewalk.
You can speak in public parks.
You can distribute literature in lawful public forums.
But you cannot force your way into a privately owned church and disrupt a worship service.
That distinction is important. A church service is not a political rally. Turning that space into a stage for confrontation crosses a line our society has long recognized.
Ohio HAS TAKEN Action to Protect Worship
Unfortunately, these incidents are not isolated.
After protesters disrupted a Mass at St. Joseph Cathedral in Columbus in 2021, Ohio lawmakers recognized that existing penalties were not sufficient to deter deliberate disruptions of religious services.
As a result, the General Assembly passed the Sacred Spaces Act (House Bill 504). This law strengthened penalties for the “disruption of a lawful meeting” when the intent is to disturb religious worship.
As Yost put it plainly:
“You have a right to speak; you don’t have a right to speak everywhere at any time in any manner.”
Ohio will not treat the intimidation of churches as harmless political theater.
Churches Should Be Prepared, Not Paranoid
For many congregations, disruptions feel like something that happens “somewhere else.”
Attorney General Yost encouraged churches to be prepared, not fearful, and to take reasonable steps to protect their congregations while preserving the spirit of worship.
He recommends a practical, three-part approach:
1. Develop a Security Plan: Every church building is different. Leaders should consider:
Where people enter and exit
How hallways and sanctuaries are laid out
Where children’s areas are located
Knowing how to manage movement during an emergency is essential.
2. Delegate Responsibility: Pastors should not be expected to handle disruptions alone. Yost advises assigning a trusted elder, deacon, or staff member with the specific responsibility of contacting law enforcement if needed, so the pastor can remain focused on shepherding the congregation.
3. Use Private Security When Possible: For churches with sufficient resources, trained security personnel at entrances can help prevent situations from escalating and can respond quickly if a threat arises.
These measures acknowledge the reality that worship services are no longer automatically respected by those who seek confrontation.
Preparation protects peace.
Guarding Your Christian Witness
Perhaps the most sobering part of Yost’s warning has nothing to do with criminal law.
Yost cautioned that many disruptions are more focused on provoking a reaction than anything else.
In today’s digital culture, outrage is currency. A single angry exchange, recorded on a phone, can be edited, shared, and weaponized within minutes.
“They want you to blow your witness,” Yost warned.
“They want you to act hateful so they can get it on camera.”
That reality places an added burden on churches, not only to protect their people, but to protect their testimony.
Yost offered four important principles for congregations:
Teach calm, not confrontation.
Members should know in advance that leaders will handle disruptions and that emotional responses only serve the disruptors’ goals.Protect children and vulnerable individuals first.
Safety always comes before argument.Allow law enforcement to act independently.
This is not the congregation’s role, and trying to manage it internally can make matters worse.Maintain a posture of Christian love, even under pressure.
Firm boundaries and lawful consequences can coexist with Christlike conduct.
Standing for truth does not require abandoning grace. And defending worship does not require surrendering our witness.
Choosing Hope Over Fear
As troubling as these incidents are, Attorney General Yost offered one final reminder that resonates deeply with the Christian faith:
Do not let darkness set the tone of your life.
Believers are not called to retreat, to hide, or to surrender public space. But neither are we called to live in constant anxiety, expecting hostility around every corner.
Our mission remains unchanged:
Preach the Gospel
Disciple families
Serve communities
Love our neighbors
No protest, no viral video, and no moment of public outrage can alter that calling.
“Let’s not let the darkness determine our moods,” Yost said.
And Center for Christian Virtue will continue to stand boldly in the public square to ensure that Ohio remains a place where faith is not silenced, worship is not intimidated, and families can gather in peace.
#####
Photo credit: Fibonacci Blue, ICE OUT protest in Downtown Minneapolis (2026-01-23), https://www.flickr.com/photos/44550450@N04/55058688158/
