Back

LifeSiteNews: "Slitting organ donors’ necks will not increase trust in transplant system"

The proposal addresses Normothermic Regional Perfusion, a practice critics say blurs the line between life and death.

Nov 20, 2026Center for Christian Virtue1 min read

LifeSiteNews: "Slitting organ donors’ necks will not increase trust in transplant system"

The Health Resources and Services Administration has invited public comments through December 28, 2026, on a policy proposal involving Normothermic Regional Perfusion, or NRP, in organ retrieval. The recommendation would have surgeons clamp and vent the blood vessels supplying a donor’s brain before resuscitating the rest of the body for organ procurement.

NRP begins after medical support is withdrawn and a donor’s heart stops. Death is then declared under the Uniform Determination of Death Act’s circulatory-respiratory standard, which requires the irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions. Because some organs can be damaged while the heart is stopped, NRP restarts circulation to preserve organs for transplant. The blood supply to the brain is blocked so the donor does not regain brain function or awareness during that process.

Several physicians and ethicists have challenged the practice. In 2021, the American College of Physicians recommended pausing NRP, saying “the burden of proof regarding the ethical and legal propriety of this practice has not been met.” University of Colorado bioethicist Matthew DeCamp and colleagues wrote in 2022 that restarting circulation “reverses what was just declared” to be irreversible.

In 2024, transplant surgeon Dr. Claire Morgan filed complaints with federal regulators and the national transplant network. She said blood flow to the brain in NRP donors is not always fully blocked and that she had witnessed multiple cases where brain blood flow was incompletely occluded. In an interview, she said, “We have seen signs of life in NRP when the brain has been reperfused.” Morgan has called for a moratorium on NRP procedures, and she said the new recommendation is insufficient because many surgeons already clamp and cut the vessels supplying the brain.

Sources

Share this
More like this

Your gift funds the testimony, research and grassroots pressure that move votes where laws are made.

Proclaiming Christ. Defending Virtue.
Protecting Families.
Donate

Get CCV in your inbox.

Daybreak is CCV’s newsletter. The day’s headlines brought to light. Subscribe free.

No spam. We never share your info. Unsubscribe anytime.

© 2026 Center for Christian Virtue. All rights reserved.SearchPrivacy policyFinancial accountabilityMedia requests